Sold Benin Bronzes
||The British Museum (BM) has sold more than 30
Benin bronzes since World War II, according to a file that has been declassified
at the request of The Art Newspaper. Most went to Nigeria and were bought for
under £100, although fine examples currently fetch up to £100,000. The
selloffs are now strongly regretted by BM curators.
See also African Travel for other cities
related on African art
back to news or more about British
Museum dotation from Blair african
art in London
found at: Forbes.com Connoisseur's
read also: The British
The bronze plaques were seized during the British
"punitive expedition" against the Benin ruler in 1897, and since
Nigerian independence in 1960 there have been numerous calls for the return of
the royal treasures. Last January the lower house of the Nigerian Parliament
unanimously called on the federal government to submit an official request for
the return of the Benin bronzes.
A newly declassified 1972 report to the BM trustees
admits that the Benin bronzes were "booty" but were nevertheless
legally acquired by the museum. It has been no secret that a few BM bronzes were
sold in the 1950s, but for different reasons neither the museum nor the Nigerian
authorities have been keen to draw attention to the sales. Only now has the full
extent of the de-accessioning become apparent. It also comes as a surprise that
two Benin plaques were disposed of as late as 1972
The story of the selloffs began in 1950 when Keeper of Ethnography Hermann
Braunholtz reported to BM trustees that of the 203 plaques acquired from the
Foreign Office in 1898, "about 30 are to all intents and purposes duplicate
specimens, and therefore surplus to the Museum's requirements." He proposed
selling 10 for £1,500, since "there are hardly any in the country
[Nigeria]." The proceeds were put toward the purchase of the important
Oldman collection of African and American ethnography.
The selloff served two purposes. Plans were being made
in Lagos, Nigeria, to establish a national museum, in what was then still a
British colony. Curators in London altruistically wanted to see important
examples of Benin culture on display in the Nigerian capital. But in addition,
sales would be helpful in raising funds to enable the ethnography department to
expand the range of its collection.
After the initial sale, the Nigerians were keen to
purchase further plaques, but the BM was concerned about the difficulty in
valuing them, since they rarely came onto the market. The solution adopted now
seems bizarre: The BM decided to sell four bronzes to a London dealer as a
"test." As Braunholtz proposed to the trustees, "It would be
desirable to ascertain their approximate present value in the open market. This
could be done by offering a few typical pieces for the sale to a reliable dealer
to sell them on commission."
London dealer Sydney Burney was brought in, and he sold
four BM plaques for £1,100, with the museum receiving £876 after deduction of
commission. The following year a further 13 plaques (including two acquired
after 1898) were sold to the Nigerian government for £1,050, with an average
price of £75.
De-accessioning continued. In 1951 another plaque was
exchanged with Nigeria, and a year later three bronzes, valued at £450, were
given to New York dealer J.J. Klejman in partial exchange for an important Benin
horseman. A further plaque was sold to Nigeria in 1953, and the following year
another went to West Africa, although it is unclear whether it was to Nigeria or
the Gold Coast.
In 1958 a BM bronze was sold to Klejman for £450. On
June 27, 1960, a plaque depicting an oba, or king, was auctioned at Sotheby's,
where it fetched £900 and was acquired by a Zurich collector. Nigeria became
independent on Oct. 1, 1960, and after that only two further bronzes were
In 1972 William Buller Fagg, who had become the BM's
keeper of ethnography, proposed an exchange with Robin Lehman, the London-based
son of New York banker Robert Lehman (an extremely generous donor to the
Metropolitan Museum). Two plaques of mudfish and a crocodile were to be swapped
for an important bronze horseman in Lehman's collection. Financially, it was
advantageous for the museum, since the two plaques were then valued at £4,000-5,000
and the horseman at £8,000-10,000.
The decision to regard some of the bronzes as
"duplicates" now seems astonishing. Even Fagg admitted that they were
duplicates only "because the figures on them occurred, not necessarily in
the same arrangement, on other plaques." In other words, if there were two
bronzes with a profile of a leopard, one was deemed to be a
"duplicate," even though they were individually modeled and cast. This
is almost like suggesting that if a European sculptor had made a pair of figures
of saints, one could be regarded as surplus.
Even if the 1950s de-accessioning was appropriate for
its time, further questions remain about the 1972 swap with Lehman. Under the
1963 British Museum Act, the legal constraints on de-accessioning were
tightened. Surprisingly, neither curators nor trustees seem to have inquired too
closely into whether the plaques of a mudfish and a crocodile could really be
classified as duplicates.
The sell offs and exchanges are now regarded as very
unfortunate by museum staff. "From a curatorial point of view, it was a
curse. The bronzes were cast in matching pairs, so it is difficult to exhibit
them properly," BM African specialist Dr. Nigel Barley said last month. The
plaques had decorated wooden columns that supported the roof of the oba's
palace, and pairs of motifs had been displayed on opposite sides of the
In the BM's new Sainsbury African Galleries, opened
last year beneath the Great Court, the 48 finest Benin Bronzes are displayed on
a large, square-shaped metal frame. But unfortunately there are very few pairs
Despite Fagg's altruistic action in helping the
fledgling Lagos museum, little of the Nigerian collection of Benin Bronzes is
currently on display, and there are fears that some of it may have been
misappropriated. Professor Frank Willett, formerly a curator in Nigeria and
later director of the Hunterian Museum in Glasgow, Scotland, alleges that
"almost the entire reserve collection of Benin antiquities" was
missing in Lagos in the early 1980s while a traveling exhibition of
"Treasures of Ancient Nigeria" was abroad. Since only five plaques
were in the "Treasures" show (three of which had originally been in
the British Museum), this raises questions about the whereabouts of the 20 or so
others that came from the BM and the dozens of others bought from other sources.
In spite of rumors about the National Museum's reserve
collection, there has been no independent verification of what has happened to
the bronzes. But although very few of the plaques have been seen in recent years
at the Lagos museum, there is no evidence that its plaques have come onto the
market. The hope, therefore, is that they are still in store.
However, the security situation at Nigerian museums
does give ground for considerable concern. In this situation, there is unlikely
to be much pressure on the BM to return more Benin Bronzes. In London the finest
plaques are on display in an excellent new gallery, presented there in the
context of world culture. The remaining plaques in the reserve collection are
accessible to anyone with a serious interest.
Nevertheless, the fact that the BM was willing to
de-accession until as recently as 1972 does provide a precedent--and this will
be seized upon by those who believe that the Benin Bronzes should be returned to
© 2002 The Art Newspaper
DO NOT HESITATE TO POST MAIL YOURSELF ABOUT THE ART YOU LOVE.
Visit the British
Museum website (in London Bloomsbury) and its Sainsbury African
galleries (from the ex-Museum of Mankind)
African masks from Known Collections
African Art Collectors,
Discover the African
Art books I like or join me on
Antiques is the archive and not growing much anymore but still updated.
Art to join our free newsletter and read recent African Art News.
For the last news about British-Museum-sold-Benin-bronzes you should join our African
Art Club and become an insider of the African art market.
And if you are a collector of African Art,
have a look at our exclusive African
Art Collection for sale.
Call us at +32 3 227 35 40
african art | home
| african art shop
Tribal Arts of Africa
Author: Jean-Baptiste Bacquart
more African Art books I like